The short version
- A theater is a room with one job. A media room is a living space that is also good for a movie.
- The room decides more than the equipment does.
- Projectors need a dark room. Televisions do not.
- Speaker positions have to be chosen before the drywall, whichever you build.
The difference in one paragraph
A home theater is a room that exists to show movies and games as well as they can be shown. It has a door that closes, it can be made dark, the seats face one way, and everything about it, from the paint color to where the speakers go, is chosen for the picture and the sound.
A media room is a room people live in: a family room, a den, a bonus room over the garage. It has windows, a couch that faces the fireplace as much as the screen, and probably a kitchen within earshot. It has a good TV and good sound, worked in so they do not take over the room.
Neither is the lesser choice. A media room that the family uses every evening is a better buy than a theater that is used twice a year.
Side by side
| Media room | Dedicated theater | |
|---|---|---|
| The room | Shared with everyday life | Used for watching and little else |
| Light | Daylight and lamps, most of the time | Can be made fully dark |
| Picture | A large television | A projector and screen, or a very large television |
| Sound | A soundbar, or speakers set into the walls and ceiling | A full surround layout, with speakers placed by the seating plan |
| Seating | The furniture you already like | Seats in rows, every one with a clear view |
| Sound leaving the room | It will. Open rooms share their sound with the house | Can be contained, if that is planned in the walls |
| Best for | The game, the evening's TV, family movie night | Movies and games as an event |
Four questions that decide it
Do you have a room to give up?
A theater needs a room that does nothing else. If the only candidate is the room where the children also play and the family also sits, you are building a media room, and that is fine.
Can the room be made dark?
A projector throws light at a screen, and any other light in the room washes the picture out. A room with a wall of west-facing windows is a television room. A room with one small window, or none, can take a projector.
How do you really watch?
If most viewing is sports on a Saturday afternoon with people coming and going, you want a bright television and sound that reaches the whole room. If it is a movie on a Friday night with the lights off and the phones away, a theater is worth the effort.
Who else is in the house?
Movie soundtracks have real bass, and bass travels through floors and walls. A theater next to a nursery needs the walls built for it. A media room that is open to the kitchen will be heard in the kitchen whatever you do.
Television or projector
For years the rule was simple: televisions for small screens, projectors for big ones. Televisions have grown, and that line has moved, but the principle holds.
- A television makes its own light. It looks good with the lamps on and the sun out. For any room with daylight, it is the right answer.
- A projector gives the largest picture and the feeling of a movie theater, in a room that is dark. The screen matters as much as the projector, and so does where the projector hangs.
How large should the picture be? It depends on how far away you sit. A common starting point is to sit roughly one and a half times the screen's diagonal away, closer if you like to be surrounded by the picture and farther if you do not. In a theater the seating distance is chosen first and the screen follows. In a media room the couch is usually where it is, and the television is sized to suit.
What the speaker numbers mean
Surround sound layouts are written as two or three numbers, and they are simpler than they look.
- The first number is the count of speakers around you at ear level: front left, center, front right, and the surrounds beside and behind.
- The second is the number of subwoofers, which handle the deep bass.
- The third, when there is one, is the number of speakers overhead, for sound that moves above you.
So 5.1 is five speakers around you and one subwoofer. 7.1 adds two more behind. 5.1.2 is five around, one subwoofer and two overhead.
The center speaker matters most. Nearly all dialogue comes from it, and "I cannot hear what they are saying" is almost always a center speaker that is missing, too small or pointed at people's knees.
In a media room, the speakers can be set into the walls and ceiling and painted to match, so the room does not look like a showroom. A soundbar is a reasonable step up from a television's own speakers where in-wall speakers are not practical. In a theater the layout is drawn around the seats. Home Theaters shows the common layouts as diagrams.
The room is half the sound
The same speakers sound different in different rooms. Hard surfaces reflect sound, so a room with a tile floor, bare walls and a lot of glass rings and blurs speech. Soft things absorb it. A rug, upholstered seats, curtains and a full bookcase do more for clarity than most people expect.
In a theater this is planned: where sound is absorbed, where it is scattered, and how the walls are built so that the bass stays in the room. In a media room the furnishing does most of the work, and it is worth knowing that before choosing a hard floor and bare walls for the room with the big TV.
Decide before the drywall
Whichever room you are building, the decisions that are hard to change are in the walls.
- Speaker cable to every speaker position, including the ceiling.
- A cable for the subwoofer, and more than one possible spot for it.
- A conduit behind the television or to the projector, so cables can be replaced later.
- Data cable to the screen and to wherever the equipment will sit.
- Somewhere for the equipment that has air around it and is not the screen wall.
- Lighting on dimmers, so the room can go from bright to dark at a touch. See Lighting Control.
In a finished house most of this can still be done; it takes more work. In a new build it is an afternoon. The pre-wire guide has the full list.
One last test: can everyone work it?
The best system is the one that the whole family can turn on. If watching a movie takes three remotes and a phone call to whoever set it up, it will not get used. Ask for one simple control that starts everything with a single press, and ask to be shown it before the installer leaves.
Start with Media Rooms if the room is one you live in, or Home Theaters if it has a door and a single purpose. We will come and look at the room either way.
Written by the team at Security Solutions, Inc. in Brighton, Tennessee. General guidance, not a quote for your house: every home is different, and we would rather look at yours than guess.