The short version
- Permanent lighting costs more at the start and nothing in labor each year after.
- By day the track is hard to notice from the street. Up close, you can see it.
- The lights run from their own app, separate from your alarm.
- Check your neighborhood rules before you buy either kind.
What permanent roofline lighting is
Permanent roofline lighting is a row of small LED lights mounted along the edge of the roof, usually in a slim track under the eave or along the fascia, spaced evenly and pointed down the wall. A controller, normally in the garage or attic, tells each light what color to be. You run it from an app on your phone.
Because every light can be any color, one installation covers the whole year: warm white on an ordinary evening, red and green in December, red, white and blue in July, orange in October, your team's colors on a Saturday. Most systems can also be set to plain bright white, which is useful when you want to see the yard.
It is a different thing from the string lights in a box in the attic, and from the floodlights and path lights that light a yard. It follows the roofline only.
Side by side
| Hanging lights each year | Permanent roofline lighting | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost at the start | Low | Considerably higher |
| Work each year | Up the ladder in November, up again in January, or pay someone both times | None |
| Other holidays | A new set of lights and another trip up for each | Change it from the app |
| Look by day | Wires and clips for the weeks they are up, nothing the rest of the year | A track along the eave all year. Hard to notice from the street, visible up close |
| Look at night | The classic look. Bulb styles to suit any taste | Even dots of light washing down the wall. Cleaner, less traditional |
| Wear | Clips break, strings fail, storage tangles | Outdoors all year in sun, heat and storms, so the quality of the parts and the mounting matters |
| If you move | They go in a box | It stays with the house |
We have left prices out on purpose. The cost of permanent lighting depends on the length of the roofline, how many stories and peaks it has and how the wire has to be routed, and a number made up for a web page would be wrong for your house. A measured quote is free.
The ladder is the real cost
The price of a box of string lights is not what people are weighing when they ask about permanent lighting. They are weighing a cold afternoon on an extension ladder, twice a year, every year.
That is a fair thing to weigh. A fall from roof height is a serious matter, and a roofline is a long reach at an awkward angle. On a single-story ranch with a low eave it is a chore. On a two-story house with a steep gable it is a job for someone with the right equipment, which is why many families already pay to have their lights hung and taken down.
If you already pay for that each year, add up a few seasons of it. That is the honest comparison.
The drawbacks of permanent roofline lighting
- You can see it in daylight if you look. A track that matches the trim color is easy to miss from the road. Standing on the porch looking up, you will see it. Ask to see photographs of a daytime installation on a house the color of yours.
- It is attached to your house. The track is fastened to the soffit or fascia. Ask how it is attached and what happens if a section ever has to come off for a gutter or roof repair.
- It needs power and a home for the controller. There is a power supply and a control box, and wire from there to the roofline. On a long roofline, power has to be fed in at more than one point so the far end is as bright as the near end.
- It has its own app. The lights are run from their own app. They are separate from your alarm system.
- Your neighborhood may have rules. Some homeowners' associations restrict exterior lighting, colors or the months they may be on. Read the covenants before you sign anything.
- Your neighbors can see it too. A slow warm white is welcome on most streets. A fast color chase at midnight is not. The app has a schedule; use it.
Kits you install yourself
There are permanent lighting kits sold for homeowners to install. If you are comfortable on a ladder and patient with wiring, they can work. Go in knowing what the job involves.
- It is the same ladder, for longer. Mounting a track neatly along the whole roofline takes far more time up there than clipping on a string.
- Corners and peaks are the hard part. Straight runs are easy. The joints at gables, valleys and corners are where a clean job is won or lost, and where wire is hardest to hide.
- Long runs dim. Low-voltage lighting loses power over distance. Without extra power fed in along the run, the lights at the far end are dimmer and the whites drift toward yellow.
- Every outdoor connection has to be sealed. Water finds the one that was not.
- The kit decides the spacing. A kit comes in fixed lengths. An installer cuts the track and spaces the lights to fit your roofline.
A professional installation costs more than a kit. What you are paying for is the measuring, the ladder time, the power planning and somebody to call if a section goes out.
Questions to ask any installer, including us
- Can I see the track in daylight on a house like mine?
- How is it attached to the house, and what does the trim look like if it is ever removed?
- Where do the controller and power supply go, and how does the wire get from there to the roof?
- What is covered if a light or a section fails, and for how long? Get it in writing.
- Who comes out to fix it, and from where?
- Does it do a plain warm white and a plain bright white, not just colors?
- Can it be set to turn itself on and off, and to follow sunset?
The Permanent Holiday & Roofline Lighting page describes how we go about it, and lets you try colors and patterns on a drawing of a house. For the back of the house, see Outdoor Living.
So which should you choose?
Keep hanging lights if you have a low, simple roofline, you enjoy the ritual, you only decorate at Christmas, or you expect to move in a year or two.
Look at permanent lighting if the roofline is tall or steep, you already pay someone to hang lights, you would use it for more than one holiday, or you would like a soft light on the front of the house every evening and not only in December.
Either way, check the neighborhood rules first.
Written by the team at Security Solutions, Inc. in Brighton, Tennessee. General guidance, not a quote for your house: every home is different, and we would rather look at yours than guess.